SWBG blog
Does the Draft Scottish Budget Meet Women’s Needs? The Women’s Economic Empowerment Group Discuss
The women’s economic empowerment group met after the Cabinet Secretary presented her budget to Parliament last week. The discussion focused on whether they felt their needs and the needs of women reflected in the budget decisions taken.
The Cabinet Secretary mentioned care 15 times, tax 16 times, poverty 5 times and investment 23 times while disabled/disability and women weren’t mentioned at all. Despite this, it could be argued that a number of the announcements made could benefit both women and disabled people. This included increased funding for wraparound care, funding for colleges to support disabled people into employment, and the increase in Scottish Child Payment for Under1’s from 2027.
The overall feeling of the group was that, while the Cabinet Secretary had said some positive things about areas they cared about, they weren’t sure that the funding allocated would actually make a difference in their lives. For instance, women shared their experiences of having difficulties getting GP appointments and of having their health concerns taken seriously. They felt that the additional funding to primary care and, in particular, to the walk-in GP clinics could make a difference. However, they were unclear how long this would take and if they and their families would benefit from the decisions taken anytime soon. They also queried what funding would be available to address the health inequalities experienced by women, who despite the publication and delivery of the Women’s Health Plan in 2021 are experiencing longer waiting times to access gynaecological services.1
The group had questions about whether budget decisions recognised the interconnectedness of the systems that we interact with. They highlighted this in relation to the announcement of funding for the Summer of Sport and the offer of free-swimming lessons. They questioned whether this budget announcement took any cognisance of decisions made in recent years at the local authority level to close or reduce the opening hours of facilities, and how funding to local authorities in general would support the delivery of these services. They queried whether disabled children would benefit from these announcements, and if the funding would be enough to address the barriers they often experience.
They also questioned whether additional funding for employability support would support more parents into work without addressing the challenges posed by the current childcare offer, or how, without changes in employers’ willingness to employ and support disabled people, this funding would lead to more disabled people accessing good-quality employment.
After listening to the Cabinet Secretary’s announcement, the questions posed to her afterwards and her responses, the group’s reaction was: “You can tell we are in an election year.” However, despite being in an election year, there were things the group felt were missing from the budget statement. While they welcomed the introduction of the mansion tax and the taxing of private jets, they felt that further changes were needed to make the system more progressive overall. They were also concerned about social care. While it had been mentioned, they weren’t convinced that the Budget paid enough attention to the problems being experienced across Scotland or to the recommendations made by the local government committee in their pre-budget scrutiny.
Finally, there was a lack of optimism that these announcements would make a difference to them and their families due to the way these will be delivered at a local level.
Conclusion
All in all, the group were left with a mixed feeling. While they recognised that the Budget included some positive announcements, it ultimately failed to tackle some systemic problems, such as the undervaluation of care and problems with implementation.
Reaction to the Scottish Budget 2026-27
This blog will be updated over the coming days as we take time to go through the budget documentation.
Today’s budget made some important steps but lacked transformative action for women.
On taxes, we welcome the introduction of additional council tax bands for those in high value properties. Yet, today’s announcements shy away from delivering full scale reform, and revaluation remains essential to ensure fairer local taxes capable of adequately funding local services. The introduction of a private jet tax is also a positive step, targeting some of the wealthiest individuals for their highly polluting journeys and reinforcing the Government’s mission to addressing the climate emergency.
On the spending side, this budget contained several key announcements which, while welcome, fall short of ambition. SWBG joined many anti-poverty charities in calling for Scottish Child Payment to rise to £40 per week. The commitment to implement this increase for children under one is a step in the right direction but must quickly be followed with eligibility for all children.
We were disappointed by the absence of any funding to fulfill the Scottish Government’s commitment to end non-residential social care charging. The difference between statements made in today’s budget on social care funding and the reality of rising charges and tightening eligibility at the local level highlights the persistent gulf between the social care budget and the investment actually needed. The percentage increase in social care spending lags behind that of the NHS. It remains to be seen if this spending will resolve the NHS’ performance challenges; however, the absence of a focus on social care, which is also preventative, will only increase pressure on the NHS.
On childcare, this budget appears to increase the focus on school aged provision, with the announcement of a national breakfast club offer in all primary schools and the expansion of after-school activities clubs for children. This is an important development that will be welcomed by families across Scotland, particularly women, who disproportionally bear the brunt of balancing paid work and caring responsibilities. However, this announcement falls short of the Scottish Government’s commitment to deliver a national school age childcare system by the end of this Parliament, with the deadline now pushed to August 2027.
By contrast, Early Learning and Childcare (under 5s) sees no change, despite calls for reform to allow children to access their funded entitlement when they turn three, rather than from the following term. Meanwhile, the original ambition to develop an ELC system from one onwards appears to have faded, with no further news on support for eligible children or on widening the criteria for eligible two-year-olds to help close the attainment gap.
Today’s budget continues to adopt the traditional outlook of economic growth and the transition from oil and gas industries. Supporting workers in oil and gas to reskill to work in renewables is positive, but it falls short from transformative change, both in terms of increasing women’s representation in these sectors and widening our understanding of the economy. The omission of care as a key economic driver is glaring, undermining its role in supporting a well-functioning economy and forming a crucial part of the country’s social infrastructure.
Finally, alongside tax and spending measures, the budget announced £1.5 billion in efficiencies through Public Sector Reform. At SWBG, we have consistently stressed that such reforms must not exacerbate gender inequality. We will be reviewing the details over the coming days to assess the potential impact.
Women’s Voices on Pre-Budget Scrutiny: Perspectives from the Women’s Economic Empowerment Group
In the run up to the introduction of the Scottish budget for 26-27, our Women’s Economic Empowerment group looked at the pre-budget scrutiny undertaken by two parliamentary committees: the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee and the Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee.
The pre-budget scrutiny process aims to give committees greater influence on the formulation of the budget, improve transparency and raise public understanding and awareness of the budget.
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
The Health, Social Care and Sport Committee chose to look at mental health spending and how decisions on this area supported the delivery of the government’s priorities.
The Health, Social Care and Sport committee conducted its pre-budget scrutiny by issuing a general call for evidence that ran from 26th to 15th June. They also wrote directly to all health and social care partnerships requesting information. The call for evidence received 51 responses, 39 of which were from organisations. Additionally, the Committee held three evidence sessions hearing from eight people: three academics, three public sector workers and two representatives from the third sector, only one of whom was a woman.
The women who took part in our session queried why the committee didn’t hear directly from people with lived experience as part of their pre-budget scrutiny. They felt this could have aided the committee’s understanding about the way decisions taken to balance budgets had impacted on individuals who relied on services and those who provided care. This could have provided additional insight into how well current funding was helping to achieve the Government’s priorities.
The group also felt the language used in the evidence sessions and in the recommendations made by the committee could have been more accessible.
The committee’s findings on the need for greater transparency in order to “follow the money”, and to increase the focus on the outcomes achieved from this investment, echo what the group had learned about the key principles of gender budgeting, and highlight that these are essential if budgets are to drive change and achieve government priorities.
Given members of the group’s varying experiences of accessing services, and the postcode lottery that has developed, they are particularly interested in hearing the Government’s response to the committee’s call for the ring-fencing of certain elements of funding.
The group felt that the need for greater accountability, and for better linking of decisions taken at a local level to achieving the priorities set out by Government, is essential if individuals in communities across Scotland are to experience better outcomes.
Local Government, Housing and Planning committee
The Local Government, Housing and Planning committee sought to understand how the Scottish budget supports the Scottish Government and Local Government’s ambition to “work together strategically to advance public service reform”.
This committee took a different approach to their scrutiny. They wrote to key stakeholders inviting them to provide evidence. This closed call for evidence limited who the committee heard from.
The group were interested in why the committee decided to limit who they invited to hear from as part of their pre-budget scrutiny, and how this might have impacted on the breadth of evidence they heard.
The committee found that, while the Scottish Government is aiming to change public services ‘to be preventative, to better join up and be more efficient’, increased demand was impacting budgets and reducing the funding available for preventative approaches. The committee recommended that the budget must recognise the challenges of increased demands for councils’ services, in particular social care delivery.
Conclusion
While the two committees took slightly different approaches, a key question from members of the Women’s Economic Empowerment project was how these approaches helped meet the aim of improving transparency and raising public understanding of the budget. The lack of public or lived-experience involvement was clear, highlighting the need for more inclusive engagement to ensure that policy decisions reflect the realities of the communities parliamentarians aim to serve.
The group will also be keeping an eye on whether the committees’ recommendations influence the budget published next week, particularly in relation to social care delivery
Women’s Voices on the UK Budget: Reflections from Our Economic Empowerment Project
In this blog, our Training Lead, Heather Williams, shares the reflections of the women who are taking part in our second Economic Empowerment project.
What is a budget? This one, like those that have gone before, was a political occasion, except this was one that had been played out in the press for weeks before, with one policy trailed after another, testing the mood of the ‘nation’, or more accurately of the press pack and the opposition.
As the Chancellor stood last Wednesday to make her statement, was her priority ensuring the lines on the spreadsheet added up providing enough fiscal head room to keep the markets happy? Was it about keeping Labour MPs onside and keeping manifesto commitments? Was it about creating some positive headlines for what is seen by many in the press as a failing administration or about making decisions which make life better for people across the UK? In reality, it was probably about all of these.
But how did the decisions made land with a group of women from across Scotland? Our women’s economic empowerment group had mixed feelings about the Chancellor’s statement. They were pleased that the two-child limit had been abolished. Despite some of the headlines of the national newspapers about this being a budget for benefits street, there was a recognition of how self-defeating pushing children into poverty was as a policy choice.
The Chancellor’s statement that we will all have to pay a little more was questioned about what a little more to Rachel Reeves would look like for those on low incomes and how effective the measures she was taking to reduce household costs would be. There was little hope in the group that changes would curb the ever-increasing costs that households are facing.
The silence from the Chancellor on care was deafening! A quick check on the words used in her hour-long speech shows that she used the word tax 75 times, investment 36 and care on four occasions. The lack of any mention about the social care sector, which is crumbling across the UK, highlights an inability across governments to understand that investment in this area is needed if we are to generate economic growth.
The decision to limit the types of cars that can be accessed through the mobility scheme was a sop to the red tops and their mantra that the UK is a country of shirkers and strivers. That shirkers shouldn’t be rewarded. This policy change won’t save the treasury a penny as the amount subsidised is the same if a disabled person uses it for a BMW or a Ford. All this decision does is send the message that disabled people don’t deserve to have access to the same things as others in society as they are seen as shirkers, an example of groups being pitched against each other.
Another lesson from this budget is never believe a politician that tells you that they will not raise taxes! Or who treats tax like it’s a shameful thing failing to recognise the contribution taxes make towards the services we receive.
Some of the women on this group have direct experience of the harm caused by the failure to invest in public services. They were clear that further investment was needed particularly in areas like social housing, social care and violence against women services. As we look forward to the Scottish Government’s budget statement in January, these are some of the areas women hope to hear more about than we did from the Chancellor.
Labour’s second budget, did the Chancellor get it right?
Blog by Sara Cowan, Director, and Carmen Martinez, Policy and Engagement Lead
After weeks of speculation about what measures would feature in her second budget, the Chancellor has finally delivered her Autumn Statement. As always, it is a mixed bag—but this budget does include some measures worth celebrating from a women’s equality perspective.
Let’s start with the most obvious win: an end to the two-child limit. After years of mounting evidence—and thanks to the tireless work of many organisations and individuals, including those under the banner of the End Child Poverty Coalition—the UK is finally seeing the end of this punitive policy. The result? Around 350,000 children will be lifted out of poverty, and a further 700,000 will find themselves in less deep poverty.
In Scotland, the Scottish Government had already committed to mitigating the two-child limit. However, today’s announcement will free up the £155 million that was to be allocated to achieve this commitment. This extra funding should be directed toward other policies aimed at tackling child poverty in line with the government’s priorities, for example increasing the rate of the Scottish Child Payment. Yet with the benefit cap still in place, the Scottish Government will need to continue to cover costs of mitigating its impact.
Another announcement that will have a significant impact on women is the decision to support families with three or more children by increasing the maximum amount of childcare costs they can claim through Universal Credit. Equally important as introducing new measures is ensuring that existing policies work effectively. In this regard, it is reassuring to see a written commitment for the Department for Work and Pensions to reassess overpayments caused by incorrect operational guidance on averaging fluctuating earnings, and to begin reducing, cancelling, or reimbursing debts previously collected from affected carers from 2026.
While the focus on social security is welcome, the UK budget’s biggest omission remains social infrastructure. There was no mention of care infrastructure or support for care services, childcare or social care —provisions that are essential for advancing women’s equality. This is an area we will hope to hear a lot more about in the Scottish Budget, particularly regarding critical investment in social care services that could support the delivery of the Scottish Government’s commitment to ending non-residential social care charges.
Another highlight of the budget was the increase in the minimum wage and the move to equalise earnings for younger workers. For women, who are more likely to be on lower wages, including many childcare workers, this increase is particularly significant. However, we continue to call for payment of at least the real living wage to all those working in the care sector, with higher wages for frontline roles in social care and childcare, to recognise the skilled nature of the work.
Pivoting to announcements that support a Just Transition, it’s encouraging to see that the government will introduce energy relief, saving households £150 on electricity bills. A closer look at the budget papers reveals that “energy costs will be reduced by the ending of the Energy Company Obligation, which is currently funded through bills, and through the government funding 75% of the domestic cost of the legacy Renewables Obligation for three years.”
This focus on alleviating the cost of living is important. After all, energy costs are the second-highest single expense making women worse off, according to our annual women’s survey. Yet the Energy Company Obligation was a scheme requiring large energy companies to help low-income and vulnerable households heat their homes via energy efficiency improvements or heating system upgrades. Its removal could represent a step backwards in decarbonising our homes, delivering a Just Transition, reducing bills in the long-term and effectively tackling climate change. A further review of the budget papers will hopefully clarify where support for a Just Transition will come from and what this might mean for Scotland.
Finally, a lot has been said about taxes. What’s been presented in the budget is a missed opportunity for fundamental improvement to our tax system. While small steps were taken for what the Chancellor said would be the wealthiest contributing the most this fell short of significant change such as fully matching taxing income from work and from wealth or consideration of a broader wealth tax.
It was also encouraging to see changes to both the higher rate of Air Passenger Duty (APD) - known as a Private Jet Tax - and the Soft Drinks Industry Levy. While APD does not directly apply to Scotland, as it is a devolved tax, the Scottish Government could follow suit to support its efforts in tackling the climate emergency. As for the Soft Drinks Industry Levy, much attention has been paid to milkshakes. However, growing evidence links sugar and ultra-processed foods to worsening health outcomes. From a financial perspective, it is fair to say that the NHS cannot continue shouldering the costs of market failures.
So, to return to our initial question: the Chancellor’s overdue changes to the social security system are very much welcome. Yet a key takeaway from this budget has to do with the absence of investment in social infrastructure, particularly in care. We need far bolder action to improve our public services—even if that means breaking manifesto promises.
Mailing list
To join our email list, simply enter your email address below.
